What is the best – shingle roof or metal roof?

What is the best – shingle roof or metal roof? 

Choosing the right roofing material for your home is pretty overwhelming when there are a lot of options available in the market. However, keeping in view the importance of your roofing material choice and its impact on durability and longevity, you need strict criteria to use.

Your home’s roof is a quite hefty investment and you need to make a well-informed decision to keep maintenance and repair annoyance at a bay. Among the variety of available roofing materials, the two popular choices are metal and asphalt shingles. Your pick for roofing material has to be resistant against wind and fire besides offering the best protection against unexpected weather events.

To make your life simple, we’ve put together this thorough guide for choosing the best roofing material among asphalt shingles or metal roofs. So, let’s jump in without wasting the next second.
Metal vs Asphalt Shingle Roof

If you’re looking for a roof that’s easier to install and is cost-effective, asphalt shingle has a lot to offer. But with overtime improvement in product quality, metal roofs deserve consideration being a durable and long-lasting roofing material.
Finish Options

Gone are the days when metal roofs were merely corrugated tin panels having the look of a barn or shed. Now, you can find metal roofs in the spectrum of colors and finishes that can even mimic the look of shingle, slate, and shake styles. You can see metal roofs from California contemporaries to East Coast Victorians. The shingle roofs, following the same trend, have come out of the traditional look of their own. You can now give your home the look of a slate roof at a reasonable cost with shingle roofs. The same stands true to wood shakes and tile roofing looks. So, you can get the look of whatever style you want equally from both the materials.


If you’re more interested in the roof’s durability and standing up against Mother Nature, metal roofs tend to be a preferred choice. It comes with warranties of up to 50 years and often outlasts the lifespan of 40 to 70 years unless severe weather is faced or you walk improperly on the roof. In comparison to this, asphalt shingles tend to have a shorter lifespan. Things like dampness or pooling water can even further reduce the life of your shingle roof. That’s the reason why shingle roofs come with warranties of 15 to 30 years only depending on the area or region you’re living in.

Cost consideration

Now here is the lick, if you pick metal roofing because of durability and longevity, you’re likely to pay the price at the time of installation. The price for metal roofs is way more than the asphalt shingle and the installation is also a more specialized job. So, at the end of the day, it’s more like your own preference, what you’re looking out of this roofing material.


Metal roofs are mostly made up of recycled and reclaimed materials that can further be recycled without much hassle. So, metal roofs are more eco-friendly and sustainable if you’re rather concerned about the environment.

Ease of Installation & Repair / maintenance

Unlike metal roofing, installing an asphalt shingle roof is much easier to do and it only requires little specialized knowledge. The installation typically takes a day or two especially when you have to install the roof over the existing layer. On the other end, installing a metal roofing is a bit more precise and a special job.

The bottom Line

Now, that you know the pros and cons of both metal and shingle roofing, it’s the time to pick one for your home. As you see, both have their own set of pros and cons so it’s all about your personal preference and demands. If you’re still confused about your choice, contact us now and we’ll guide you through the process. We’re a renowned roofing company in Burford, GA and have been helping our clients for many years.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *